You just got approved for the new place. Congratulations!
You love the commute, you love the neighborhood, and you really love the fact that the price of rent is easily within your budget. But even so, there’s a problem:
Your insurance broker keeps saying that you have a choice between getting replacement value and actual cash value for your belongings — and you have no idea what either of those terms mean.
By the numbers, 1 out of every 20 insured homes will file a claim each year. And the risk of fire, property damage, or natural disaster is always on the horizon for renters as well.
But even so, is replacement value right for your insurance needs? Read on to see how these coverage options can impact your insurance policy protection.
What is Replacement Value?
Imagine that you’ve purchased an incredibly expensive mattress and bedroom set. The cost of importing those handwoven rugs and purchasing that four-poster bedframe alone was well over five figures.
In the event that your property has been destroyed by an insured peril, your insurance provider has two options:
- They can pay for the cost of repairing your personal possessions
- They can pay for the cost of replacing your lost items with something of similar quality
If you’ve opted for a replacement value payout, it won’t matter how old your bedroom set is and you won’t be arguing with the adjuster about depreciation. You’ll receive a payment that will allow you to replace your destroyed belongings with items of similar quality and similar features.
What is Actual Cash Value?
Let’s go back to the example of your lavish bedroom set. But this time, you’ve opted out of your replacement value policy and decided to go with actual cash value.
In this case, you can ignore all the things we just said about depreciation not factoring into the cost. You’ll be paid out based on the present-day value of the items that have been destroyed.
What are the Pros and Cons of Each?
On that note, why would a savvy insurance buyer opt for actual cash value? Are there any drawbacks associated with purchasing replacement value insurance? Here’s a general overview of the benefits and downsides of each insurance option:
Replacement Value Pros and Cons
If you choose to purchase replacement value insurance, you may expect a slightly higher payout. Here’s what you should know about the general pros and cons:
Replacement Value Pros
- You’ll be able to replace your lost items with items of similar quality
- Depreciation isn’t calculated into your payout
Replacement Value Cons
- You can expect to pay significantly higher monthly premiums with this type of insurance
- You may not necessarily receive an exact cash exchange simply because the insurance company will be looking at the cost of purchasing an item with similar features to the one that you’ve lost
If you’re not worried about monthly insurance costs and you like the idea of being able to rebuild your life without compromise, replacement value insurance has a lot going for it.
Actual Cash Value
So we’ve just covered the ins and outs of replacement value insurance policies. Does the logic apply to actual cash value insurance?
Actual Cash Value Pros
- You’ll likely be spending less on your monthly insurance premiums
- The payout you receive may still be adequate if you’re willing to be a bit thrifty
Actual Cash Value Cons
- You may have to supplement your payout with your personal savings to get adequate replacements for the items you’ve lost
- Deductibles may lower your payout even further when you’ve opted for actual cash value
Actual cash value is a budget-friendly form of insurance. If you’ve got a substantial financial cushion and you’re not sure about what type of insurance to get, actual cash value can be very adequate.
Which Insurance Option Should You Choose?
At the end of the day, there’s no right or wrong way to insure your property. The details ultimately come down to factors like your property value, your budget, and your risk profile.
In addition to standard property insurance, the best renters insurance policies will cover your liability options along with your property concerns. After all, being in an apartment instead of a house won’t save you from being sued if a guest or neighbor is injured while visiting you.
Simply because insurance can be complicated, however, you may want to shop around before committing to a policy. From deductible amounts to monthly premiums, costs, and coverage for visitors, you need a renters insurance policy that has your back. By working with an insurance professional or an assessment service, you can be sure that your insurance plan is up to the task.
Should You Opt for Replacement Value Insurance?
When you’re excited about your new place and your insurance clauses are largely academic, the whole replacement value vs actual cash value debate can feel an awful lot like splitting hairs. But when the worst-case scenario has happened and you’re scrambling to rebuild your life, these distinctions could be the difference between purchasing new items outright and having to supplement your purchases with your savings.
As you consider your insurance options, you’ll want to consider factors like your monthly budget, your savings, and your policy limits. Plus, on top of the clauses that apply to your possessions, you’ll also want to carefully weigh your liability coverage options. Regardless of whether you’ve got a lot of items or you’re a minimalist, replacement value insurance can give you peace of mind and better insurance coverage.
Was this article helpful to you? Explore the rest of our site to find more content like this!